JUSTICE STRIKES TWICE: Mubende MP Sent Home, Bugweri MP Disqualified.

user 14-Nov-2026 National News
JUSTICE STRIKES TWICE: Mubende MP Sent Home, Bugweri MP Disqualified.

By Musa Rwamigoye. 

 

MUBENDE: The High Court has nullified the election of NRM’s Dedan Mubangizi as Buwekula South Member of Parliament and ordered a fresh election, after finding that a recount which overturned his opponent’s victory was based on compromised electoral materials.

Acting High Court Judge Mary Babirye, in a judgment delivered on Friday, November 13, 2026, declared the seat vacant and ordered Mubangizi to leave Parliament immediately.

“The 1st Respondent was not validly elected, and his election is set aside,” Babirye ruled.

 “No other candidate is declared elected on this record. A fresh election for the directly elected Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency shall be held as if it were a by-election.”

 

The ruling followed a petition by independent candidate Fred Tumwesigye, who was initially declared winner of the January 15 election with 8,804 votes against Mubangizi’s 7,998. NUP candidate Edward Sempiira obtained 1,915 votes.

However, a court-ordered recount conducted on January 27 and 28 reduced Tumwesigye’s votes to 7,504 and Mubangizi’s to 7,908, handing the NRM candidate victory by 404 votes.

 

Missing Ballots.

Justice Babirye found that 1,426 valid votes were lost from the original tally during the recount, with Tumwesigye accounting for 1,300, or 91.2 percent, of the reduction.

 “The unexplained loss from the Petitioner’s recorded total exceeded the original margin,” the judge observed.

 “The Returning Officer’s tested evidence and the general assertion that the recount corrected errors did not provide a coherent reconciliation of that change.”

 

At Namalewe Life Centre Compound polling station in Kyabaduuma, a ballot box contained 300 unused ballot papers and seven used booklets, but no cast ballots or Declaration of Results Form.

“A complete absence of those ballots is not a counting correction,” Babirye said.

At Kayebe Health Centre II, Tumwesigye’s votes dropped from 100 to just one, while Mubangizi’s increased from 145 to 147.

The court also documented torn electoral packaging, missing declaration forms and failures to establish whether the seals on ballot boxes were the original ones.

“An unbroken seal may be original or a replacement. What excludes an unauthorised replacement is credible traceability,” the judge said.

“The records, direct polling evidence and tested custodial evidence satisfy the Court that the challenged recount materials were materially compromised.”

 

Returning Officer Implicated.

The court found that Mubende Returning Officer Ferdinand T. Mulekezi had failed to discharge his statutory responsibility for safeguarding electoral materials.

During cross-examination, Mulekezi admitted that there was no custody register or inventory of unused electoral seals.

Babirye found that his unexplained omission fell within Section 97(g) of the Parliamentary Elections Act, which provides for offences arising from breaches of official electoral duties.

“This finding concerns his own official omission. It is not a finding that he personally removed particular ballots, replaced a particular seal, or acted at the direction of the 1st Respondent,” she clarified.

The court directed that the judgment be forwarded to the Director of Public Prosecutions for investigations into the handling of electoral materials between January 15 and 28.

The DPP was directed to report its findings within 15 days of receiving the judgment.

 

Fresh Election.

Despite nullifying Mubangizi’s election, Babirye declined to declare Tumwesigye the winner, saying the available evidence could not conclusively establish who had won the constituency.

“The failure of the recount does not, without a further evidential finding, prove every figure in the original return,” she ruled.

“Nor can the Court fill the evidential gaps by awarding missing votes to either candidate.”

 

The judge said ordering another recount would not restore the missing ballots or electoral records.

“The Court must protect the voters’ actual choice, rather than presume which candidate the unavailable materials would have supported.”

Babirye directed the Electoral Commission to organise a fresh election across the constituency and ordered Mubangizi, the Commission and the returning officer to jointly and severally pay Tumwesigye’s legal costs.

“The 1st Respondent shall vacate the seat of Member of Parliament for Buwekula South Constituency forthwith,” she ordered. 

 

BUGWERI: COURT NULLIFIES WOMAN MP ELECTION OVER ACADEMIC QUALIFICATIONS, DECLARES RUNNER-UP WINNER.

IGANGA: The High Court in Iganga has nullified the election of Bugweri District Woman MP Nankwanga Stella Maris over failure to present the required academic qualifications at the time of nomination, declaring her closest challenger, Aminah Mutesi Nalugoda, the duly elected MP.

In a judgment delivered on November 13, 2026, Justice Simon Peter Kinobe ruled that Nankwanga was not qualified to contest in the January 15, 2026, parliamentary elections because the academic documents she presented to the Electoral Commission did not meet the legal requirements for nomination.

The court consequently set aside her election and declared Nalugoda, who finished second, the duly elected Woman MP for Bugweri District.

Nankwanga had been declared winner with 15,151 votes beating Nalugoda, who obtained 13,683 votes. Another candidate, Mercy Walukamba, came third with 10,767 votes.

 

The dispute centred on Nankwanga’s academic qualifications, particularly a Post Basic Diploma in Public Health and a Certificate in Mental Health Nursing, which she presented during nomination.

Nalugoda argued that the Post Basic Diploma in Public Health presented by Nankwanga was not recognised by the National Council for Higher Education (NCHE) as an equivalent of Advanced Level education.

She also challenged Nankwanga’s failure to present a certificate of equivalence for her Certificate in Mental Health Nursing.

In her defence, Nankwanga maintained that she possessed the minimum academic qualifications required to contest for Parliament. She told the court that she had an Ordinary Level certificate, a Certificate and transcript in Mental Health Nursing from Butabika School of Psychiatric Nursing, and a Diploma in Public Health from Medicare Health Professionals College.

She explained that the college had made errors in the description of her academic award and subsequently corrected the documents to reflect a Diploma in Public Health.

However, the court established that Nankwanga requested the college to correct her academic documents on December 3, 2025, after the parliamentary nominations held on October 22 and 23, 2025.

The college responded on January 5, 2026, confirming that she had obtained a Diploma in Public Health and undertaking to issue corrected academic documents.

Justice Kinobe held that the subsequent correction could not retrospectively cure the failure to present the required academic documents at the time of nomination.

The judge further noted that the NCHE had confirmed that the Post Basic Diploma in Public Health presented during nomination was not accredited.

On the Certificate in Mental Health Nursing, the court observed that although the 2015 legal notice recognises certain nursing qualifications as equivalent to Advanced Level, Nankwanga was required to obtain and present a certificate of equivalence from the NCHE.

The court found that she had not submitted the required certificate to the Electoral Commission at the time of nomination.

The judge also faulted the Electoral Commission for failing to determine a formal complaint lodged by Nalugoda’s agent, Byakuno Majidu, challenging Nankwanga’s academic qualifications before the elections.

The Commission argued that it had invited the complainant and Nankwanga to attend a hearing on January 12, 2026, but the complainant failed to respond to the invitation.

However, Justice Kinobe held that the failure by Nankwanga to appear at the hearing could not extinguish a complaint raising a fundamental question about her eligibility to contest.

The judge observed that the Commission had a legal obligation to examine and determine the complaint, adding that the failure to resolve it allowed an unqualified candidate to participate in the election.

The court further ruled that the law requires parliamentary candidates to possess the prescribed academic qualifications at the time of nomination and that documents obtained or corrected later cannot validate an otherwise defective nomination.

In determining the appropriate remedy, Justice Kinobe relied on provisions of the Parliamentary Elections Act that empower the High Court to declare another candidate duly elected where the declared winner is found not to have been qualified.

He noted that Nalugoda had obtained the second-highest number of valid votes and would therefore become the candidate with the highest lawful votes once Nankwanga was excluded from the contest.

The judge said ordering a fresh election would impose additional costs on taxpayers and could trigger unnecessary tensions among voters when the law provided for the runner-up to take the seat.

The court consequently allowed Nalugoda’s petition, declared Nankwanga’s election invalid and ordered the Electoral Commission to recognise the petitioner as the duly elected Woman MP for Bugweri District.

The first respondent and the Electoral Commission were ordered to share the costs of the petition equally.

Related Post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Popular post